- One recent study found that highly engineered consumables may be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
- The researchers found that these foods are designed to heighten reward and hasten the delivery of reinforcing ingredients.
- The habit-forming nature of such products suggests they drive uncontrollable eating and interfere with natural hunger cues.
- The researchers suggest that ultraprocessed foods should be subject to policies comparable to those for tobacco products.
Right now, there is no single agreed-upon definition of UPFs. Certain experts classify them as foods that contain ingredients you would not find in a home kitchen, such as emulsifiers and artificial substances.
A lot of dietitians employ the NOVA classification to classify ultraprocessed foods. This talks about foods that are “combinations of components, primarily of exclusive industrial use, typically made by a set of factory processes and methods.”
A recent analysis released by The Millbank Quarterly proposed that UPFs are potentially just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
“I agree with this research, as UPFs are intentionally formulated to be highly appealing to most individuals,” noted a bariatric surgeon who was not involved in the research.
A study from 2023 estimates that more than 73% of the foods available in the United States is classified as highly processed.
“Cigarettes and ultraprocessed foods are not just natural products but highly engineered delivery systems engineered deliberately to optimize biological and psychological reward and habitual overuse,” explained the review’s authors.
Can UPFs Habit-Forming?
The paper synthesized findings from addiction, historical health policy, and nutrition in order to highlight sensory and structural characteristics that enhance the rewarding nature of both tobacco and UPFs.
“It’s not all people is ‘hooked’ to such products, but for a sizable group, they cause typical habit-forming patterns: intense desires, inability to stop, and continued use even with negative health effects,” explained a preventive cardiology dietitian.
“These foods are intentionally designed with processed carbohydrates, added fats, salt, and flavor enhancers to optimize pleasure and repeat consumption, and the food sector uses persuasive advertising strategies, especially aimed at children,” she stated.
The authors analyzed five key areas:
- delivery speed
- hedonic engineering, or designing foods to be extremely pleasurable
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “health washing”
It was observed that, like cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are fine-tuned to deliver the right dose of sugar.
“Refined carbohydrates trigger dopamine production via the vagus nerve, while fats do so via intestinal lipid sensing,” the researchers explained.
“… UPFs with significant amounts of refined carbohydrates and extra oils are some of the most highly addictive substances in the modern diet. It is key that this processed carb and fat mix is virtually absent in whole foods.”
How such products quickly deliver “feel-good” chemicals to the brain renders them potentially addictive, in a comparable way to tobacco.
The paper explained that while tobacco are designed to deliver nicotine quickly, ultraprocessed foods are formulated to rapidly digest and absorb, as they typically have minimal fiber. This makes it easier for the system to metabolize fat and sugar faster.
Authors also note that ultraprocessed foods provide deliberate flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and textures that dissolve easily. This all helps to trigger more dopamine and encourages you to consume additional amounts.
‘Health Washing’ in Tobacco, UPFs
According to the review, both the cigarette and processed food industries have long used a tactic called “health washing.”
This refers to when goods are advertised and reformulated to create an perception of reduced harm while maintaining the core addictive properties.
This tactic in the cigarette sector gained traction in the mid-20th century with the advent of filter tips on smokes.
These were marketed as safety features that would catch tar and particles before they entered the lungs. In reality, these tips offer little meaningful benefit.
However, people typically adjusted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which negated any decrease in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has adopted a comparable strategy. It employs packaging claims like “reduced fat” or “sugar-free” to market UPFs.
However, these foods still contain the very addictive formulations. The issue is that these reformulations offer a superficial appearance of health while the product’s habit-forming nature and metabolic harms remain intact.
Should UPFs Be Regulated?
The researchers stated at the conclusion of their paper that food and smoking products are not the same thing.
Still, they warned that some UPFs act like highly optimized consumables rather than real nourishment. They recommended that health regulations ought to acknowledge this reality.
“Tobacco offers a warning, and tobacco control offers a source of potential,” the researchers stated.
Due to policies, cigarette use levels in the United States have fallen and have “altered public perception of tobacco and eroded trust in the industry.”
“I believe greater awareness about the negative impact of ultra-processed foods is essential to lower public intake and enhance public health. The strategies used to curb tobacco use have been successful and could be a helpful model for UPFs as well,” said one specialist.
“I don’t think ultraprocessed foods ought to be regulated exactly like cigarettes, but they certainly deserve stronger, smoking policy-based measures: advertising limits, clear packaging warnings, tighter rules on health claims, and restrictions in educational institutions or hospitals,” noted another nutrition professional.
The researchers pointed out to people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.